Hero Image

Independent medical assessment

Health & Safety

22 May 2025 (Last updated 3 Dec 2025)

Share on:

Being a business owner and employer, you must manage different aspects of your business. These aspects include staff, their health and safety, and their wellbeing. Employers and business owners in Australia have a duty of care towards their employees and their wellbeing.

A part of this duty of care is supporting them during illness or medical emergencies. You should also have protocols in place to ensure that your staff are taking appropriate measures for safety. What happens when your employee requests medical leave? What are your responsibilities and obligations? Do you have protocols and policies in place?

In this best practice guide for employers, we outline the facets of medical reports, arranging an independent medical examination, and key things for employers to know. Please note that the information provided below is general and does not constitute advice. If you need help or support, consult a professional.

Medical reports

In Australia alone, employee absenteeism which includes but is not limited to sick leave, costs the economy billions in lost productivity. Managing absenteeism and excessive sick leave presents several challenges for business owners and employers.

There are a variety of reasons why an employer might ask an employee to provide a medical report. The reason may be as straightforward as needing a diagnosis for an injury or illness that has led the employee to be absent from work.

Alternatively, the employer may need to establish a likely return-to-work date for an employee with a long-term illness or injury. In some cases, medical reports can clarify if an employee is able to perform the intrinsic responsibilities of their role, or even give the grounds to approve a flexible working arrangement request. 

Notice and medical certificates

Employers can ask employees to provide evidence for as little as 1 day or less off work. An employee who doesn’t give their employer evidence when asked may not be entitled to be paid for their sick or carer’s leave.

Types of evidence

Medical certificates or statutory declarations are examples of acceptable forms of evidence. While there are no strict rules on what type of evidence needs to be given, the evidence has to convince a reasonable person that the employee was genuinely entitled to sick or carer’s leave.

Sometimes employers need a qualified opinion about their employee’s condition from a general practitioner (GP) or medical specialist. This is called an ‘independent medical examination’.

Independent medical examination

An independent medical examination (IME), also known as an independent medical assessment (IMA), is an examination performed by a medical specialist in order to evaluate an employee’s mental or physical health.

The purpose of an independent medical examination is to gain a more complete picture of an employee’s injury, medical condition, or disability.

An independent report from a qualified medical specialist can help an employer plan for a worker’s rehabilitation and return to work. If the injury was sustained while the employee was working, an independent medical examination can help the employer prepare in the event of a claim.

An independent medical examination provides the insurer or legal representative with an independent opinion regarding the employee’s injury and treatment to assist with decisions about their rehabilitation, recovery/return to work and entitlements to compensation.

Independent medical examiners

In many cases, it’s appropriate for a GP to perform a medical examination. However, if the employee is being treated by a specialist for a particular type of illness or injury, it’s preferable that the treating doctor carries out the examination. For instance, an employee suffering from workplace stress will most likely need an independent medical examination by a psychiatrist.

The independent medical examiner needs to be professionally trained and medically certified. They also need to be actively practising at the time of conducting the examination.

Things for employers to remember

In some cases, the employer may select a medical practitioner to perform an independent medical examination. It’s the employer’s responsibility to:

  • Pick a suitable and qualified independent medical examiner.
  • Ensure that an appointment can be made within a reasonable time period (usually four weeks).
  • Ensure the appointment is as close to the employee’s home as possible.
  • Provide all relevant appointment details and any relevant information about how the employee can prepare for the examination at least 10 days in advance.

Things for employees to remember

If an employer requests an independent medical examination, the employee has a legal obligation to attend. If an employer books an appointment for an independent medical exam, the employee should:

  • Confirm the appointment immediately. If the employee is unable to attend the appointment, they should speak to their employer to arrange an alternative date as soon as possible.
  • Let the employer or clinic know if they have any special needs, such as an interpreter or disabled access. 
  • Take all test results and radiographic films (including X-rays, MRIs, CTs, and ultrasounds) to help the examiner make a thorough assessment.

Also be aware that employees can take a support person to the appointment if needed. Advise the doctor or the receptionist if you wish to be accompanied during the examination, as the medical examiner must agree to the support person’s presence. The support person cannot act as an interpreter or answer the medical examiner’s questions. 

Can employees refuse independent medical examinations?

For a new injury or illness, employees are legally obligated to undergo independent medical examinations.

In some cases, the effects of an injury can continue for some time. It may be necessary for the employee to attend further examinations so the medical examiner can report on their progress.

If an employee refuses the directive to attend a medical examination, it should be treated as a HR issue and could result in disciplinary action.

If an employee is asked to attend more than one independent medical examination in relation to the same injury or illness, they may have a right to refuse. Employees do not have to attend any unnecessary appointments for independent medical examinations.

Additionally, the employee does not have to attend if the proposed medical examination is to assess physical or mental capabilities that are not related to the inherent requirements of their job.

Build better businesses with Peninsula

With constant legislative changes and increasing employer responsibilities, it can be tricky to keep up with your duties. At Peninsula, you can speak to experts, and access industry specific resources for your business. With Peninsula, you can get 24/7 advice, support, and resources for all your HR and health and safety matters.

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute as business or legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. It does not take into consideration your specific business, industry or circumstances. You should seek legal or other professional advice regarding matters as they relate to you or your business. To the maximum extent permitted by law, Peninsula Group disclaim all liability for any errors or omissions contained in this information or any failure to update or correct this information. It is your responsibility to assess and verify the accuracy, completeness, and reliability of the information in this article.

Have a question?

Have a question that hasn't been answered? Fill in the form below and one of our experts will contact you back.

By clicking submit you consent to our Privacy Policy

Related Guides

Health & Safety

Model Work Health and Safety Laws

Safe Work Australia is responsible for maintaining model work health and safety (WHS) laws, but they do not regulate or enforce them. In 2011, Safe Work Australia developed model work health and safety laws that would be then implemented across states in Australia. However, commonwealth and state and territory regulators will oversee and enforce the laws in their jurisdiction. For these model work health and safety laws to become legally binding, the Commonwealth, states and territories must separately implement them as their own laws. What do model work health and safety laws include? The Model Work Health and Safety Act The Model Work Health and Safety Regulations The Model Codes of Practice Background A single set of work health and safety laws were created for jurisdictions to implement in Australia. These would be known as ‘model’ laws. Each state and territory, and the Commonwealth, has its own WHS laws, including an Act, regulations and codes of practice. A National Review into Model Occupational Health and Safety Laws was conducted to make recommendations on the structure and content of a model OHS Act that could be adopted in all jurisictions. The review was carried out by a panel of three independent experts that undertook public consultation with regulators, union and employer organisations, industry representatives, legal professionals, academics and health and safety professionals. The panel made 232 recommendations and in May 2009 the Workplace Relations Ministers' Council (WRMC) set policy parameters for developing a model Act based on these recommendations. In September 2009, Safe Work Australia released a draft model WHS act for public comment. Several amendments were done to the draft and on 29 April 2010, Safe Work Australia published a final version on their website. When did the states implement model health and safety laws? Commonwealth, Australian Capital Territory, New South Wales, Northern Territory and Queensland implemented the laws on 1 January 2012 South Australia and Tasmania implemented the model WHS laws on 1 January 2013 Western Australia passed a version of the laws on 10 November 2020, and they became operational on 31 March 2022. Victoria is the only jurisdiction in Australia who has not implemented the model WHS laws as of now. Are there variations in the laws? It depends on the jurisdiction in question. Some variations in their WHS laws may be required to ensure the legislation is consistent with their other processes and laws. Get complete WHS support with Peninsula Australian health and safety laws are complex and need small business owners and employers to comply with different regulations across different states. It can be challenging to keep up with the layered health and safety laws and ensure physical and mental wellbeing of your employees. Peninsula provides complete health and safety support including policies, processes, documents, and advice for Aussie SMEs. Talk to our team today to learn how we can help you. This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute as business or legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. It does not take into consideration your specific business, industry or circumstances. You should seek legal or other professional advice regarding matters as they relate to you or your business. To the maximum extent permitted by law, Peninsula Group disclaim all liability for any errors or omissions contained in this information or any failure to update or correct this information. It is your responsibility to assess and verify the accuracy, completeness, and reliability of the information in this article.

Health & Safety

Manual Handling

If you are a small business owner or employer, your employees may be involved in some manual tasks at work. These could include picking up things or detailed actions including physical effort. By definition, manual handling is the act of pushing, pulling, or using other bodily force to lift and carry loads. Many businesses require their workers to perform some manual handling. Whether it’s retail workers stacking shelves or factory workers assembling products on conveyor belts. Any task, if performed poorly, incorrectly, or for too long – can pose a risk of injury. The most common types of injury are lower back pains, neck pain, and problems with shoulders and arms – including forearm, elbow, wrist, hand, and fingers. These injuries can result from lifting a heavy or unbalanced load only once, or from continually lifting a heavy or unbalanced load. Sometimes these injuries lead to permanent disability and expensive compensation claims. You can reduce disruption to your business by reviewing the tasks your employees do manually and working out how to avoid injuries. Examples of manual handling Regardless of what industry you are involved in, many businesses require their workers to do manual handling tasks that are potentially harmful. Even remaining stationary for long periods can result in short or long-term injury. Some examples of manual handling tasks include: Pushing and pulling trolleys Operating machinery Packing boxes Lifting heavy equipment or objects Leaning over to scan grocery items or wash dishes. Types of manual handling injuries Understanding the type of manual handling required in the workplace, and the effect it has on the human body can go a long way to preventing injury. Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most common type of injury and disease that occurs due to manual handling. These injuries affect the musculoskeletal system (i.e. bones of the skeleton, ligaments, joints, and cartilage) and restrict movement of the human body. Depending on the activity that leads to the injury, MSD can occur in the form of: Sprains, strains, and direct blows to muscles, ligaments, and tendons. Back injuries include damage to the muscles, spinal discs, nerves, joints, and bones. Injuries to joints and bones, along with injuries to the shoulder, neck, arms, elbows, legs, knees, wrist, hip, hands and feet. Soft tissue injuries (e.g. hernias). Chronic pain that lasts for three months or longer. Acute pain that lasts for less than three months. Muscular and vascular disorders as a result of hand or arm vibration. Some manual tasks may also be hazardous or dangerous. Hazardous manual tasks are tasks that require a person to lift, lower, push, pull, carry or otherwise move, hold or restrain any person, animal or thing that involves one or more of the following: Repetitive or sustained force. Repetitive movement. High or sudden force. Sustained or awkward postures. Exposure to vibration. Hazards can come from work tasks and how they’re performed or poor work design and management. They can also be the result of physical work environments or the way tools, equipment and objects are handled. Steps to reduce manual handling injuries – training and risk assessment Teaching your employees how to correctly perform manual tasks is an effective way to prevent injuries and avoid expensive claims. Many private training organisations offer face-to-face training at your chosen location and convenient online courses to suit your needs. By professionally training your workers on proper manual handling techniques, they will learn how to: Identify the risks and hazards of manual handling. Be familiar with workplace safety requirements and obligations. Correctly use mechanical aids. Adopt the correct lifting techniques. Handle different manual handling scenarios related to their role or position In some cases, you may not need formal training to identify and manage a risk. Introducing mechanical aids or making small changes to work processes or procedures can go a long way to minimising risks. The weight of the load is critical but also important is the frequency of lifting, posture while lifting, the surrounding environment, and the employee’s physical fitness. When you assess any manual handling, always consider the task, individual, load, and environment. You should also have manual handling posters around the workplace to inform employees how to perform certain tasks correctly. Make sure your employees always follow the operating instructions and limitations set by the manufacturer of any products or equipment they are handling. You can eliminate risks of manual tasks or manual handling with good work design. For example, automating any task or systems to eliminate the need for workers to carry loads. Workers compensation Employees who become sick or injured due to work are, in most circumstances, entitled to compensation. Employers must help sick and injured employees gain access to the advice, guidance, and financial support they need to recover and, where possible, return to work safely. Compensation claim payouts are given to employees in one of three ways: Directly from the insurer to the employee. From the insurer through to you. Through an approved workers’ compensation regulator. Each state and territory has its regulations when it comes to workers’ compensation. Therefore, how and where you go to submit a worker’s compensation claim and the amount of money the employee can expect to receive, will depend on the relevant state and territory. Peninsula can advise you on best practices in manual handling. For peace of mind, call our 24/7 helpline.

Health & Safety

Managing health and safety at work

Good health and safety standards always start with the people at the top. Directors and board members have collective and individual responsibility for health and safety, no matter how big or small your business is. Their role in ensuring health and safety is vital for good governance. Health and safety laws place responsibility for health and safety on the people in charge of the workplace and, on top of that, they have a duty of care to employees. By maintaining high standards of health and safety you see several benefits.  With high standards of health and safety, you protect the workplace and business from any bad publicity or employee unrest that would follow a serious accident or prosecution. Why is managing health and safety important? Research shows that managing health and safety at work effectively is good business practice. You could enjoy the financial benefits of: Increased productivity when following safe operating procedures Reduced insurance premiums Fewer absences for sickness Better employee retention and morale Reduced costs of training replacement employees. Who is responsible for managing work health and safety? According to Safe Work Australia, duty holders who have a role in managing work health and safety include: persons conducting a business or undertaking (PCBUs) designers, manufacturers, importers, suppliers and installers of plant, substances or structures, and officers Managing health and safety Managing health and safety at work involves risk management and a consistent approach to health and safety. You also need the involvement and cooperation of your workers, partners, and other businesses you work with. Key things to remember are: get involved in health and safety issues so that you understand hazards and risks associated with your operations consult your employees and other duty holders on the hazards and risks invest time and money in health and safety ensure that all employees are aware of their health and safety responsibilites and have the knowledge and training to do tasks safely practice what you preach Risk management An effective risk management process has four steps and they need to be followed carefully. Identify hazards- find out what can cause harm or risk to your workplace Assess risks- Understand what the nature of harm could be, how serious is it, and the likelihood of it happening Control risks- Introduce effective control measures that is reasonably practicable Review hazards and control measures regularly to ensure they are working as planned When to use a risk management approach? While you should have regular and ongoing risk management systems and policies, there are few times in particular that may need additional risk management. Examples of when you should review and implement your risk management include: starting a new business expanding or purchasing an existing business changing work practices, procedures or the work environment changing organisational structure or job roles introducing new workers or returning workers to the workplace purchasing new or used equipment or using new substances working with a new supplier for your services planning to improve productivity or reduce costs new information about workplace risks becomes available responding to workplace incidents (even if they have caused no injury) responding to concerns raised by workers, health and safety representatives or others at the workplace required by the WHS regulation for specific hazards Want WHS support? Are you using free online health and safety policies and templates to save costs? Standardised online policies and templates do not take into account the unique needs of your industry and business. Peninsula offers customised WHS documents and policies at optimum prices for business owners and employers. Call us on 1300856135 to find out how we can help you. This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute as business or legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. It does not take into consideration your specific business, industry or circumstances. You should seek legal or other professional advice regarding matters as they relate to you or your business. To the maximum extent permitted by law, Peninsula Group disclaim all liability for any errors or omissions contained in this information or any failure to update or correct this information. It is your responsibility to assess and verify the accuracy, completeness, and reliability of the information in this article.

Do you have any questions regarding Health & Safety?